«Задачи и этюды» - 2016

В качестве заставки, решил использовать обложку переиздания первых восьми выпусков.

Недавно были подведены итоги годового конкурса, проводимого журналом «Задачи и этюды».
На конкурс поступило 23 этюда 16 авторов из 7 стран.
Судьёй выступил известный немецкий этюдист Мартин Мински.
По его мнению «the quality level was mediocre».

Hlinka & Kekely #5316 and #5317: I think such technical endings with 2 rooks & bishop
against queen are not interesting for a human being.
Arestov #5319: There are too many captures in the introduction. Of course, the mate is not new.
Campioli #5321: The introduction with too many captures has nothing to do with the idea on the
end.
Zinar #5322: The author published already a lot of studies with this theme.
Kasparyan #5394: Nice but too small and there is not a really connection between the two main
lines.
Kasparyan & Gasparyan #5395: anticipated by Enevoldsen 1966 (HHdbV#47745). Moreover
this is only a new introduction of an old study by Kasparyan 2009 (HHdbV#4912).
Tarasiuk #5398: I don’t like the introduction with 4 captures. I think this is too brutal for this
nice festina lente idea.
Garcia #5399 and Katsnelson #5402: I’m afraid but I see only a lot of correct moves without
point.
Hlinka & Kekely #5400: The point is a 6 man position with reciprocal zugzwang (from the
database?). This position with rook & bishop against bishop & knight is not understandable for a
human being because in general this ending is a draw and not a win in more than 40 moves! 5
captures are a too high prize for making a thematic try.
Prigunov #5401: Rook sacrifice and two knight promotions, but 5.g4xRh5 is unforgivable.

Предлагается следующее распределение отличий...
Итоги: *.pgn; *.pdf.
P.S. Сергей Дидух о конкурсе: Задачи и Этюды 2016
P.P.S. «Задачи и этюды» - 2015

№ 1​

№ 2​

№ 3​

№ 4​

№ 5​

№ 6​

№ 7​

№ 8​

№ 9​

№ 10​

Все этюды конкурса с комментариями в формате *.cbv.