Назовите десять лучших на ваш взгляд рок-композиций.

Вот с этого места прошу поподробнее! Интересно...

Willy то есть вашу десятку без номеров не надо включать в опрос?
Ежели надо - прошу всё-таки номера проставить.

Обновляю списки
Zeppa, stirlitz, Puraev_Artemiy, dmitry_t, Tigrolex, Sibarit, immortal223 , kit, ber-viking , Crest , WinPooh, korsar274, miptus, Kirr, LLIaxMaTep, Ivrin, Блаженный_Поэт, Willy
27.01.2012

Код:

1) Queen - The Show Must Go On = 49
2) Queen - Bohemian Rhapsody = 31
3) Deep Purple - Child In Time = 29
4) Deep Purple - Smoke On The Water = 28
5) Pink Floyd - High Hopes = 25
6) The Beatles - Let It Be = 25
7) Pink Floyd - Keep Talking = 20
8) Scorpions - Still Loving You = 19
9) Led Zeppelin - The Rain Song = 18
10) Metallica - Nothing Else Matters = 18
11) Pink Floyd - Shine On You Crazy Diamond = 18
12) The Beatles - Yesterday = 18
13) Led Zeppelin - Stairway To Heaven = 17
14) The Beatles - I Want You = 17
15) Nirvana - Smells Like Teen Spirit = 16
16) Pink Floyd - Another Brick In The Wall = 16
17) Queen - Who Wants To Live Forever = 16
18) Deep Purple - Highway Star = 15
19) Pink Floyd - Sorrow = 15
20) Scorpions - Wind Of Change = 14
21) The Animals - The House Of The Rising Sun = 14
22) Sting - Shape Of My Heart = 12
23) Eagles - Hotel California = 11
24) The Beatles - While My Guitar Gently Weeps = 11
25) The Doors - Light My Fire = 11
26) Blue Oyster Cult - Astronomy = 10
27) Deep Purple - April = 10
28) Iron Maiden - Fear Of The Dark = 10
29) Jimi Hendrix - Midnight = 10
30) Metallica - Disposable Heroes = 10
31) Scorpions - Lonesome Crow = 10
32) The Beatles - Come Together = 10
33) Boston - More Than A Feeling = 9
34) Genesis - Home By The Sea = 9
35) Guns N' Roses - November Rain = 9
36) John Lennon - Imagine = 9
37) Led Zeppelin - Dazed And Confuzed = 9
38) Led Zeppelin - Kashmir = 9
39) Led Zeppelin - Whole Lotta Love = 9
40) Metallica - Mama Said = 9
41) Metallica - Master Of Puppets = 9
42) Metallica - One = 8
43) Pink Floyd - Atom Heart Mother = 8
44) Pink Floyd - Comfortably Numb = 8
45) Radiohead - 2+2=5 = 8
46) Uriah Heep - Lady In Black = 8
47) Barclay James Harvest - Rock'n'roll Star = 7
48) Black Sabbath - The Warning = 7
49) Eric Clapton - Tears In Heaven = 7
50) Jethro Tull - Bourree = 7
51) Led Zeppelin - Since I've Been Loving You = 7
52) Metallica - Ride The Lightning = 7
53) Ozzy Osbourne - Goodbye To Romance = 7
54) Rammstein - Los = 7
55) The Beatles - I Am The Walrus = 7
56) Deep Purple - Soldier Of Fortune = 6
57) Depeche Mode - Stripped = 6
58) Elton John - Goodbye, Yellow Brick Road = 6
59) John Lennon - How Do You Sleep? = 6
60) Lillian Axe - The World Stopped Turning = 6
61) Metallica - Fade To Black = 6
62) Pink Floyd - Yet Another Movie = 6
63) Rammstein - Morgenstern = 6
64) The Alan Parsons Project - Eye In The Sky = 6
65) Todd Rundgren - Dust In The Wind = 6
66) Bb King - The Thrill Is Gone = 5
67) Bob Dylan - Knocking On Heaven's Door = 5
68) Metallica - Dyers Eve = 5
69) Peter Gabriel - Big Time = 5
70) Pink Floyd - Mother = 5
71) Pink Floyd - Time = 5
72) Rammstein - Links 2 3 4 = 5
73) Rolling Stones - Too Much Blood = 5
74) Shocking Blue - The Long And Lonesome Road = 5
75) Sting - Every Breath You Take = 5
76) Supertramp - Breakfast In America = 5
77) The Doors - Riders On The Storm = 5
78) Abba - Money Money Money = 4
79) Ace - How Long? = 4
80) Bob Dylan - Blowing In The Wind = 4
81) Bob Dylan - Like A Rolling Stone = 4
82) Heart - Alone = 4
83) Jimi Hendrix - Little Wing = 4
84) Metallica - Unforgiven = 4
85) Mike Oldfield - Shadow On The Wall = 4
86) Nirvana - The Man Who Sold The World = 4
87) Rainbow - All Night Long = 4
88) Rolling Stones - Paint It Black = 4
89) Rolling Stones - Satisfaction = 4
90) The Who - Love, Reign O'er Me = 4
91) Van Der Graaf Generator - Pilgrims = 4
92) Ac/dc - Highway To Hell = 3
93) Apocalyptica - Inquisition Symphony = 3
94) Black Sabbath - Paranoid = 3
95) Blur - Beetlebum = 3
96) Jethro Tull - Song For Jeoffrey = 3
97) King Crimson - Starless = 3
98) Kraftwerk - The Robots = 3
99) Peter Gabriel - Mercy Street = 3
100) R.e.m. - Losing My Religion = 3
101) Rainbow - Maybe Next Time = 3
102) Shocking Blue - Shocking You = 3
103) The Beach Boys - California Dreamin' = 3
104) Andrew Lloyd Webber - The Temple = 2
105) Buckethead - Padmasana = 2
106) Dire Straits - Sultans Of Swing = 2
107) Iron Maiden - Hallowed Be Thy Name = 2
108) Jethro Tull - Locomotive Breath = 2
109) Jimi Hendrix - Wind Cryes Mary     = 2
110) Laid Back - High Society Girl = 2
111) Nautilus Pompilius - Зверь = 2
112) Rainbow - Man On The Silver Mountain = 2
113) Rammstein - Ohne Dich = 2
114) Scorpions - In Trance = 2
115) Snowy White - Bird Of Paradise = 2
116) System Of A Down - Lonely Day = 2
117) Aerosmith - Janis Got A Gun = 1
118) Depeche Mode - Personal Jesus = 1
119) Donovan - Season Of The Witch = 1
120) Iron Maiden - Afraid To Shoot Strangers = 1
121) Jimi Hendrix - All Along The Watchtower = 1
122) Nautilus Pompilius - Скованные Одной Цепью = 1
123) Pink Floyd - Echoes = 1
124) Queen - We Are The Champions = 1
125) Rainbow - Stargazer = 1
126) Sabaton - Into The Fire = 1
127) Scorpions - You And I = 1
128) The Alan Parsons Project - I Am A Mirror = 1
129) Ufo - Doctor Doctor = 1
130) Yngwie Malmsteen - Trilogy Suite Op. 5 = 1
131) Пикник - Настоящие Дни = 1

====================================

Код:

1) Queen - The Show Must Go On = 8
2) Deep Purple - Smoke On The Water = 5
3) Deep Purple - Child In Time = 4
4) Led Zeppelin - Stairway To Heaven = 4
5) Pink Floyd - High Hopes = 4
6) Queen - Bohemian Rhapsody = 4
7) Metallica - Nothing Else Matters = 3
8) Pink Floyd - Keep Talking = 3
9) Scorpions - Wind Of Change = 3
10) The Beatles - Let It Be = 3
11) The Beatles - Yesterday = 3
12) Black Sabbath - Paranoid = 2
13) Deep Purple - Highway Star = 2
14) Eagles - Hotel California = 2
15) Iron Maiden - Fear Of The Dark = 2
16) Led Zeppelin - The Rain Song = 2
17) Nirvana - Smells Like Teen Spirit = 2
18) Pink Floyd - Another Brick In The Wall = 2
19) Pink Floyd - Shine On You Crazy Diamond = 2
20) Pink Floyd - Sorrow = 2
21) Queen - Who Wants To Live Forever = 2
22) Scorpions - Still Loving You = 2
23) Sting - Shape Of My Heart = 2
24) The Animals - The House Of The Rising Sun = 2
25) The Beatles - I Want You = 2
26) The Beatles - While My Guitar Gently Weeps = 2
27) The Doors - Light My Fire = 2
28) Abba - Money Money Money = 1
29) Ac/dc - Highway To Hell = 1
30) Ace - How Long? = 1
31) Aerosmith - Janis Got A Gun = 1
32) Andrew Lloyd Webber - The Temple = 1
33) Apocalyptica - Inquisition Symphony = 1
34) Barclay James Harvest - Rock'n'roll Star = 1
35) Bb King - The Thrill Is Gone = 1
36) Black Sabbath - The Warning = 1
37) Blue Oyster Cult - Astronomy = 1
38) Blur - Beetlebum = 1
39) Bob Dylan - Blowing In The Wind = 1
40) Bob Dylan - Knocking On Heaven's Door = 1
41) Bob Dylan - Like A Rolling Stone = 1
42) Boston - More Than A Feeling = 1
43) Buckethead - Padmasana = 1
44) Deep Purple - April = 1
45) Deep Purple - Soldier Of Fortune = 1
46) Depeche Mode - Personal Jesus = 1
47) Depeche Mode - Stripped = 1
48) Dire Straits - Sultans Of Swing = 1
49) Donovan - Season Of The Witch = 1
50) Elton John - Goodbye, Yellow Brick Road = 1
51) Eric Clapton - Tears In Heaven = 1
52) Genesis - Home By The Sea = 1
53) Guns N' Roses - November Rain = 1
54) Heart - Alone = 1
55) Iron Maiden - Afraid To Shoot Strangers = 1
56) Iron Maiden - Hallowed Be Thy Name = 1
57) Jethro Tull - Bourree = 1
58) Jethro Tull - Locomotive Breath = 1
59) Jethro Tull - Song For Jeoffrey = 1
60) Jimi Hendrix - All Along The Watchtower = 1
61) Jimi Hendrix - Little Wing = 1
62) Jimi Hendrix - Midnight = 1
63) Jimi Hendrix - Wind Cryes Mary     = 1
64) John Lennon - How Do You Sleep? = 1
65) John Lennon - Imagine = 1
66) King Crimson - Starless = 1
67) Kraftwerk - The Robots = 1
68) Laid Back - High Society Girl = 1
69) Led Zeppelin - Dazed And Confuzed = 1
70) Led Zeppelin - Kashmir = 1
71) Led Zeppelin - Since I've Been Loving You = 1
72) Led Zeppelin - Whole Lotta Love = 1
73) Lillian Axe - The World Stopped Turning = 1
74) Metallica - Disposable Heroes = 1
75) Metallica - Dyers Eve = 1
76) Metallica - Fade To Black = 1
77) Metallica - Mama Said = 1
78) Metallica - Master Of Puppets = 1
79) Metallica - One = 1
80) Metallica - Ride The Lightning = 1
81) Metallica - Unforgiven = 1
82) Mike Oldfield - Shadow On The Wall = 1
83) Nautilus Pompilius - Зверь = 1
84) Nautilus Pompilius - Скованные Одной Цепью = 1
85) Nirvana - The Man Who Sold The World = 1
86) Ozzy Osbourne - Goodbye To Romance = 1
87) Peter Gabriel - Big Time = 1
88) Peter Gabriel - Mercy Street = 1
89) Pink Floyd - Atom Heart Mother = 1
90) Pink Floyd - Comfortably Numb = 1
91) Pink Floyd - Echoes = 1
92) Pink Floyd - Mother = 1
93) Pink Floyd - Time = 1
94) Pink Floyd - Yet Another Movie = 1
95) Queen - We Are The Champions = 1
96) R.e.m. - Losing My Religion = 1
97) Radiohead - 2+2=5 = 1
98) Rainbow - All Night Long = 1
99) Rainbow - Man On The Silver Mountain = 1
100) Rainbow - Maybe Next Time = 1
101) Rainbow - Stargazer = 1
102) Rammstein - Links 2 3 4 = 1
103) Rammstein - Los = 1
104) Rammstein - Morgenstern = 1
105) Rammstein - Ohne Dich = 1
106) Rolling Stones - Paint It Black = 1
107) Rolling Stones - Satisfaction = 1
108) Rolling Stones - Too Much Blood = 1
109) Sabaton - Into The Fire = 1
110) Scorpions - In Trance = 1
111) Scorpions - Lonesome Crow = 1
112) Scorpions - You And I = 1
113) Shocking Blue - Shocking You = 1
114) Shocking Blue - The Long And Lonesome Road = 1
115) Snowy White - Bird Of Paradise = 1
116) Sting - Every Breath You Take = 1
117) Supertramp - Breakfast In America = 1
118) System Of A Down - Lonely Day = 1
119) The Alan Parsons Project - Eye In The Sky = 1
120) The Alan Parsons Project - I Am A Mirror = 1
121) The Beach Boys - California Dreamin' = 1
122) The Beatles - Come Together = 1
123) The Beatles - I Am The Walrus = 1
124) The Doors - Riders On The Storm = 1
125) The Who - Love, Reign O'er Me = 1
126) Todd Rundgren - Dust In The Wind = 1
127) Ufo - Doctor Doctor = 1
128) Uriah Heep - Lady In Black = 1
129) Van Der Graaf Generator - Pilgrims = 1
130) Yngwie Malmsteen - Trilogy Suite Op. 5 = 1
131) Пикник - Настоящие Дни = 1

====================================

Код:

1) Pink Floyd = 12
2) Queen = 12
3) Deep Purple = 11
4) The Beatles = 11
5) Led Zeppelin = 9
6) Scorpions = 6
7) Metallica = 5
8) Jimi Hendrix = 4
9) Rainbow = 4
10) Black Sabbath = 3
11) Bob Dylan = 3
12) Jethro Tull = 3
13) Nirvana = 3
14) Rammstein = 3
15) Rolling Stones = 3
16) Sting = 3
17) The Doors = 3
18) Depeche Mode = 2
19) Eagles = 2
20) Iron Maiden = 2
21) John Lennon = 2
22) Nautilus Pompilius = 2
23) Peter Gabriel = 2
24) Shocking Blue = 2
25) The Alan Parsons Project = 2
26) The Animals = 2
27) Abba = 1
28) Ac/dc = 1
29) Ace = 1
30) Aerosmith = 1
31) Andrew Lloyd Webber = 1
32) Apocalyptica = 1
33) Barclay James Harvest = 1
34) Bb King = 1
35) Blue Oyster Cult = 1
36) Blur = 1
37) Boston = 1
38) Buckethead = 1
39) Dire Straits = 1
40) Donovan = 1
41) Elton John = 1
42) Eric Clapton = 1
43) Genesis = 1
44) Guns N' Roses = 1
45) Heart = 1
46) King Crimson = 1
47) Kraftwerk = 1
48) Laid Back = 1
49) Lillian Axe = 1
50) Mike Oldfield = 1
51) Ozzy Osbourne = 1
52) R.e.m. = 1
53) Radiohead = 1
54) Sabaton = 1
55) Snowy White = 1
56) Supertramp = 1
57) System Of A Down = 1
58) The Beach Boys = 1
59) The Who = 1
60) Todd Rundgren = 1
61) Ufo = 1
62) Uriah Heep = 1
63) Van Der Graaf Generator = 1
64) Yngwie Malmsteen = 1
65) Пикник = 1

WinPooh, а мне показалось, или у Вас в один момент в топе было Blackmore's Night - Under a Violet Moon ?
Мне почему-то показалось что кто-то её написал, а в списках у себя найти не могу. А жаль, хорошая группа.

И при чем же тут гарны хлопцы украинцы?
Пикник - замечательная питерская группа, основанная еще в 70-х и популярная на просторах Союза с 80-х.
Обладает завидным долголетием и творческим потенциалом. Был на их концерте лет пять назад. Хороши, как и прежде!

Рок есть рок, где и кем бы ни исполнялся. Хоть в Англии, хоть в Штатах, хоть в Союзе.
Лично для меня наши отечественные композиции тоже дороги, но, мне кажется, что они по качеству сильно уступают лучшим иностранным. Так что ни в мою десятку, ни в двадцатку, ни в тридцатку не войдут.

Но вкус у всех разный...

А отдельную тему про наш рок тоже можно сделать. И одно другому - не помеха. Отметился Пикник и Наутилус здесь - отметится и там. И хорошо.

Категорически не согласен. Это их, своя песня. Пусть и написанная в чужой манере. И мотивы иные, и текст иной, и проигрыш. Этот шедевр принадлежит группе Eagles - и никому другому.

А вот у Pet Shop Boys действительно чужая песня. И главный музыкальный мотив, и текст заимствованы у Элвиса. Но даже им, на мой взгляд, удалось создать своё отдельное, произведение искусства. Которое во многом отличается и в целом выше оригинала.

Например у них можно послушать всеми любимый Child in Time в новой версии. (с 2.00 начинается непосредственно Child in Time)


На мой взгляд получилось очень интересно.

Показалось. Но эту группу я тоже часто слушаю.

Альбомы - дело хорошее. Но как считать статистику по композициям?
В нынешнем виде Вашу десятку придется просто не включать в статистику.

Опять же, согласитесь, намного проще послушать отдельные, наиболее яркие композиции. А решиться взять да и слушать весь альбом неведомой группы - мало кому по силам... и по времени.
Ок, бум иметь в виду.